Episode 52: Incident Management Best Practices

Welcome to The Bare Metal Cyber CISA Prepcast. This series helps you prepare for the exam with focused explanations and practical context.
Incident management refers to the structured process organizations use to address unplanned disruptions in IT operations. An incident can be anything from a system outage to a service degradation or a user-facing failure, and the primary goal of incident management is to restore normal service as quickly as possible while minimizing impact on users and business activities. A reliable process reduces chaos, prevents cascading errors, and limits reputational and financial damage. It also ensures that teams respond consistently and effectively, which is essential in regulated environments. On the CISA exam, candidates are expected to understand the roles, workflows, and communication protocols that make up a robust incident management framework, including how those elements contribute to operational resilience.
The incident lifecycle consists of several key phases that ensure issues are detected, addressed, and resolved in a standardized way. The process begins with identification, where the incident is detected and logged in the incident management system. Classification follows, as the incident is evaluated for its urgency, impact, and priority. The diagnosis phase involves investigating the root cause and identifying potential resolutions. Once a resolution is selected, the recovery phase implements the fix and restores service. Finally, closure ensures that the incident was resolved completely, that records are updated, and that stakeholders are notified. This lifecycle must be clearly defined and consistently followed to enable auditing, root cause analysis, and process improvement, which is why auditors review each phase for evidence of execution and documentation.
Multiple roles support incident management, and clarity around these responsibilities is essential for effective response. The service desk serves as the first line of defense, receiving incident reports, performing initial triage, and providing updates. An incident manager oversees the response process, coordinates communication, and ensures escalation occurs when needed. Technical teams investigate the issue and apply fixes or workarounds. Stakeholders—including business users, IT leadership, and external partners—must be informed and engaged based on their impact and influence. From an audit perspective, it’s important to determine whether these roles are clearly defined, whether accountability is enforced, and whether escalation chains are appropriate for the size and scope of the incident. On the CISA exam, expect questions that test your ability to match responsibilities to incident types or phases.
Incidents must be classified and prioritized based on impact and urgency to ensure that limited resources are directed to the most critical issues. Classification considers how many users are affected, whether services are completely unavailable, and what business functions are disrupted. Urgency measures how quickly a resolution is needed. Together, these attributes determine the priority, typically on a scale such as P1 through P4, where P1 incidents are the most urgent and impactful. Service Level Agreements, or SLAs, define acceptable response and resolution times, while Operational Level Agreements, or OLAs, set expectations within teams. CISA candidates should understand how prioritization decisions are made and documented, and how misclassification can delay resolution or cause customer dissatisfaction. Consistent prioritization ensures predictable performance and fair resource allocation.
Logging and documentation are essential to every phase of incident management, beginning with incident creation and continuing through to final resolution. Every incident must be recorded with a timestamp, the reporter’s name, a detailed description, affected systems, classification level, actions taken, resolution details, and final approval. Supporting evidence such as log files, screenshots, chat transcripts, or email threads must be attached to the incident record. These records provide traceability for auditors, support compliance reporting, and enable future problem analysis. Inadequate logging leads to audit findings and impairs the ability to track trends. For CISA candidates, it’s important to know which elements belong in a complete incident log and how that information supports both operational improvement and accountability.
Escalation and communication are critical functions within the incident response process, especially for high-impact incidents that require immediate attention. Incidents should be escalated based on predefined rules that factor in severity, impact, and SLA compliance. Escalation can be automated through alerts triggered by thresholds, failed system checks, or prolonged outage durations. Communication plans, often structured in a tree format, identify who must be informed, how frequently updates should be issued, and what information is required in each message. These updates include incident status, estimated resolution time, known impact, and workaround information. On the CISA exam, candidates must understand how communication failures and unclear escalation paths delay response and increase business risk, making this a vital area of knowledge.
Root cause analysis, or RCA, plays a key role in determining not just what went wrong, but why the incident occurred in the first place. High-severity or recurring incidents should trigger an RCA process, in which technical teams identify underlying causes and link the incident to broader systemic issues. RCA is closely aligned with problem management, which seeks to prevent future incidents by implementing long-term fixes. Lessons learned from these reviews should be documented and shared with relevant stakeholders, and permanent changes to systems or procedures must be tracked and verified. Auditors assess whether RCA is conducted routinely, whether findings are acted upon, and whether the same incident types reappear due to lack of follow-through. CISA candidates must be able to differentiate between incident resolution and true root cause remediation.
To improve incident management over time, organizations must monitor performance through metrics and conduct regular reviews. Key performance indicators include total incident volume, average time to respond, average time to resolve, SLA adherence, and customer satisfaction. Reviewing incident trends helps identify common failure points, training needs, or underperforming systems. Post-incident reviews and structured debriefs, or post-mortems, provide a forum to discuss what went well and what could be improved. These reviews help shape future incident response, tool configurations, and communication strategies. On the CISA exam, you may be asked to interpret incident trends or recommend improvements to response procedures. Auditors must assess whether continuous improvement is part of the culture or whether the same issues repeat without change.
Modern incident management tools increase efficiency, automation, and visibility into service performance. Platforms like ServiceNow, Jira Service Desk, and BMC Helix manage ticket workflows, assign roles, enforce SLAs, and produce dashboards and reports. Integration with monitoring tools allows incidents to be created automatically when specific thresholds are breached. Chatbots and AI tools assist in triage, classification, and routing to reduce resolution time and improve consistency. However, automation must include override options and audit trails to maintain control and flexibility. Auditors examine whether these tools are configured properly, whether user access is restricted, and whether logs are retained and secure. For the CISA exam, candidates must understand how technology supports incident management while also introducing new risks if not properly governed.
When preparing for the CISA exam or conducting real-world audits, it is essential to understand how to evaluate an incident management process for completeness, speed, and control alignment. You must know how to assess the difference between incident, problem, and change management records, as well as how to identify escalation failures, missed SLAs, or inadequate communication. Effective incident management is not simply about putting out fires—it is about learning from those events, reducing repeat occurrences, and ensuring a stable, resilient IT environment. Strong incident response demonstrates operational maturity and instills confidence in stakeholders. As an auditor, your job is to validate that the organization is not only reacting to incidents but managing them as part of a disciplined, well-governed IT operation.
Thanks for joining us for this episode of The Bare Metal Cyber CISA Prepcast. For more episodes, tools, and study support, visit us at Baremetalcyber.com.

Episode 52: Incident Management Best Practices
Broadcast by